Talk:FriendDependencies

From APIDesign

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search

Theamiableapi (Talk | contribs)
(Are all module interfaces APIs?)
Next diff →

Revision as of 22:01, 19 September 2011

I have no real objections to friend relationships, although in C++ I avoid using the friend keyword. Reading this article about a new kind of dependency, I'm wodering if it wouldn't be much simpler to reserve the term API to talk about public interfaces? After all, the whole point of requiring a friend declaration is to keep the public from using the interface, right? So for all intents and purposes it is an internal interface, is it not? Even if it crosses module boundaries. While I agree that we always have software interfaces at module boundaries, I'm not convinced that calling all these interfaces APIs is a good idea. The concept of friend dependecies is a good example why.

Personal tools
buy